Efforts to Solve the Problem
Explicit strategies instruction has been implemented using
information taken from commercial programs such as the Visualization
Verbalization Program by Nanci Bell (1991) and the Lindamood
Phoneme Sequencing Program for Reading, Spelling, and Speech by
Patricia and Phyllis Lindamood (1998). In doing this, it was found that
the programs were incongruent with the curriculum the students were
learning within the classroom setting, which limited carry-over of
skills from the therapy session into the academic environment. Another
barrier to commercial programs was the number of hours needed to
properly instruct the students so they could effectively learn and apply
the skills. Since many students received a limited number of minutes
per week in speech and language therapy, adequate time was not provided
to achieve mastery of the concepts and skills. Finally, no formal
teacher training was received via in-service or conference for either program, as a result the effectiveness of the
instruction, which was based on learning the program through manuals,
was highly questionable. The end result was minimal generalization of
skills in independent reading and
listening comprehension skills from the therapy session to the classroom
setting.
In
addition to commercial based programs, training was received
in Braidy: The Story Braid created by Mary Ellen Moreau (2002), which taught children about story grammar concepts. Although
this technique was effective in developing an understanding and
retelling different types of narrative and expository texts, the effectiveness of this instruction on listening and
reading comprehension was never explored.
Based
on my own experience, students' language skills are targeted through
skills-based tasks or text related activities; however, few
clinicians explicitly teach students strategies in listening and
reading comprehension that facilitate independence outside
the therapeutic setting. Furthermore, many teachers do not provide
explicit instruction in listening and reading comprehension. The lack
of explicit instruction in language, listening comprehension, and
reading comprehension to students with LLD may cause them to be
less independent in their abilities to listen and read. This indicated
that there was a need for speech and language pathologists to conduct research in
these areas.
Back to Top