PHIL 136  Honors Colloquium in Philosophy

Spring 2008: Anarchisms

Syllabus – keep handy for reference

 

Dr. Aeon J. Skoble

341 Tillinghast, x2460

Email: askoble@bridgew.edu     Web: http://webhost.bridgew.edu/askoble

Office hours: M 10:15-11:15, TTH 1:45-2:45, or by appointment

 

Texts:

Edward Stringham (editor), Anarchy and the Law

Alan Moore and David Lloyd, V for Vendetta

L. Neil Smith, The Probability Broach

Additional readings to be distributed in class or via the course web page

 

Overview and objectives:

While some associate anarchism with violence and chaos, most philosophical proponents of anarchism have something more subtle in mind, and not always the same thing.  Many are surprised to find out, for example, that there are capitalist as well as communist conceptions of anarchism, or that many have written about legal systems in an anarchist society.  This colloquium will explore the many different philosophical defenses of and criticisms of anarchism, from the point of view of communism, liberalism, and libertarianism.  Different theories of human nature will be considered as appropriate.  We will read selections from both 19th century and 20th century anarchist thought, and we will contrast the differing perspectives on the nature of freedom that they presuppose or explore.  In addition to key philosophical texts, most of which are contained in the Stringham anthology, we will read two fictional explorations of these themes.  Other readings may be distributed via photocopied handouts or the web.

 

Requirements:

This is a one-credit class.  We will meet once a week to discuss the readings, and I expect that you will have actually read the material.  The word “colloquium” literally means we will be talking together, so don’t expect much lecturing on my part.  Our weekly meetings really will be discussions about the readings, and you won’t be able to participate if you haven’t read them.  You will write an 8-10 page paper on a topic to be determined later by mutual agreement, which is due April 28th.  In our final meeting, May 5th, we will discuss the papers.

 


General Outline, with assignments

Mondays, except as noted:


Jan 28 – Introductory material – HW: read V for Vendetta

 

Feb 4 – discussing V.   HW: chapters 1, 24, 33, + web assignments

 

Feb 11 – discussing history of anarchist thought.  HW: finish section III

 

Feb 20 (Wed) – continued discussion of history.  HW: begin reading ch. 2-9

 

Feb 25  -- discussion of anarchist theory in section I.  HW: finish section I

 

Mar 3 – continued discussion of theory.  HW: begin reading section II

 

Mar 10 – discussion of points of disagreement.  HW: section II selections tba

 

[Mar 17 --  Spring Break, no class]

 

Mar 24  continued discussion of points of disagreement. HW: section II selections tba

 

Mar 31 – discussion tba.  HW: start working through section IV

 

Apr 7 – discussion of case studies.  HW: finish section IV

 

Apr 14 – continued discussion of case studies.  HW: read Smith, finish papers

 

[Apr 21 – college is closed today, no class]

 

Apr 28   discussing Smith; papers due today

 

May 5 – Discussion of student papers