PHIL153 Ethics
Review for final exam
What is “ethics”?
Distinction between descriptive claims and normative claims
Why people have a belief vs Whether belief is true
Objectivity in ethics
Distinguished from cultural relativism
Distinguished from subjectivism
Arguments for and against
Why be moral?
Is there opposition between justice and self-interest? Between expedience and morality?
Nietzsche’s “genealogy” of morals – rejection of nihilism and authorship of values
Plato on rational self-interest
Morality and religion
Plato: is it good because God loves it or does God love it because it’s good? A question about whether goodness is intrinsic.
Natural Law: there are objective truths about morality/justice discoverable by human intellect. Manmade laws must conform to natural law to be valid.
Plato and Cicero on virtues
Thomas Aquinas on virtue and knowing the divine
Martin Luther King, Jr. – modern use of natural law theory; civil disobedience
Rationalist constructivism: Kant’s theory
Categorical imperative.
Utilitarianism:
Bentham version, Mill version
Greatest good for the greatest
number
Hedonistic conception of
pleasure in Bentham; Mill disagrees
Mill defines distinction
between deontological theories and consequentialist theories
Act-utilitarianism vs
rule-utilitarianism
Scottish enlightenment tradition
Hutcheson and the “moral
sense”
Hume and Smith on sympathy
Smith’s “impartial spectator”
Contractarianism: Gauthier
Relationship between
self-interest and cooperation
Prisoner’s Dilemma
“Morals by Agreement”
Virtue ethics
Aristotle
Virtues as states
of character conducive to human flourishing
Doctrine of the
mean
Human flourishing
distinguished from mere pleasures/contentment
Contemporary
virtue ethics
Philippa Foot
Elizabeth Anscombe
VE helps solve
motivational problem for felt obligations
VE gives us a way
to avoid Kant vs Utilitarian dilemmas
Readings: assigned selections from ch. 1; chapters 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10; Richter handout; Regan handout; Foot handout; King handout, Smith reading on website, Taylor videos
See also: slides